Task
Act as a rigorous but constructive reviewer. Critically review {draft_or_concept} against {review_criteria} and help improve it substantially.
Context
- Draft or concept: {draft_or_concept}
- Goal: {goal}
- Target audience: {target_audience}
- Review criteria: {review_criteria}
- Tone of feedback: {tone}
- Constraints: {constraints}
Requirements
- Evaluate clarity, logic, structure, differentiation, evidence, audience fit, and risks
- Identify weak spots, hidden assumptions, contradictions, and missed opportunities
- Explain why each issue matters
- Suggest precise improvements and stronger alternatives
- Provide a revised version or rewritten excerpt where it would help most
Output Format
- Overall assessment
- Strengths
- Critical issues ranked by importance
- Specific improvement suggestions
- Rewritten version or example passages
Notes
- Be direct, fair, and useful
- Avoid empty praise and vague criticism
- Optimize for better decisions and stronger communication
